Home
EN

Review of the case in 1956

  1. p. 157 Interrogation p.158
  2. p.159 Interrogation record of 27.06.56 verso p. 160
  3. p.161 Reference for the senior engineer of the Intaugol power grid
  4. p. 162 Extract from the employment record book
  5. Landau’s letter to the Central Military Prosecutor’s Office
  6. p. 165 Survey report on the charge against Landau p. 166
  7. p. 167 p.169
  8. p. 171 Note
  9. p. 172 Note on the review of the charge against Shubnikov and others. Landau’s letter p. 173 p. 174
  10. p. 175 Survey report on the charge against Shubnikov, Rozenkevich, Gorsky
  11. p. 184 Interrogation p.185 verso p.186 verso p. 187 verso

P. 157 Interrogation p.158

p. 157 Interrogation
In the present case I can testify as follows: With Pavel Davydovich Kogan, at whose request I wrote the text of the leaflet and which I handed it over, I became acquainted in 1936 or 1937 at my acquaintance Mar- galita Lvovna [illegible], who worked th- en on the editorial staff of the journal "Kuznitsa". He was a student of the literature faculty [illegible] inst. of philosophy, history and [illegible]. In conversations with him, in the apartment at [illegible] and my own, I found out that Kogan, like me, was dissatisfied with the mass arrests of Soviet citizens, being car- ried out then by the organs of the NKVD. Once Kogan told me that he knows still a number of young people whom [illegible] [illegible] had not earlier drawn in and who wanted to know, for the commission of sta- te acts, [illegible] however [illegible] who [illegible] committed this he did not say. I declared to him that this is connected [illegible] with slander and is senseless, that terror will improve nothing, and that the only path - is to state one's opinion to the masses. Then Kogan proposed to me [illegible] to set out in writing my [illegible] point of view, which I did. By this [illegible] used to bring to my house. I began this "leaflet", being deeply convinced that I am able to set this out so [illegible] [illegible], now, I see that in whom [illegible] Korets
p.158
[in the margin] 158 Continuation of the interrogation record [illegible] not sure, there is in whom [illegible] of incitement. No, again, I was guided only by a sincere [illegible] to serve the interests of the motherland, [illegible] accord[illegible] [illegible], [illegible], it seemed to me, there was being inflicted grea- [illegible] harm by the mass arrests that were taking place then. It was precisely by these motives that I was guided in drawing up the above-mentioned leaflet. It goes without saying that I among no counter[illegible] calls for the overthrow of Soviet power and never allowed the thought that the document written by me might be used for these purposes. As stated above, the leaflet written by me I handed to Kogan. This was, ap- [illegible], 25 April 1938, and on 27 April I was arrested. And at once there was present- ed to me the text of the leaflet written by me. From [illegible] how it could be I came to the convict- ion that Kogan was a provocateur. Further his [illegible] are unknown to me. To me still [illegible] about the summoning of Kogan for interrogation there was not [illegible] neither at the preliminary investig- ation in court. Recorded correctly from my words and read by me Korets Interrogated by: [illegible], [illegible] /Korkin/

P.159 Interrogation record of 27.06.56 verso p. 160

p.159 Interrogation record of 27.06.56
RECORD of the interrogation of a witness [in the margin] 159 27 June 1956 military prosecutor [illegible] Major Korkin [illegible] of the Military Prosecutor's Office interrogated the person named below as a witness in compliance with Arts. 162-168 of the Crim. Proc. Code of the RSFSR Surname, first name, patronymic Korets Moisey Abramovich Age born in 1908 Place of birth the city of Sevastopol Place of work, post and rank the city of Inta, electr[illegible] of the combine "Intaugol", sr. engineer. Marital status married, three children. Since what time in the Soviet Army — Nationality Jew Education higher In what relation he stands to the accused — Origin — Criminal record convicted Party membership non-party Permanent residence and exact address the city of Inta, Kirov St., 30a, apt. 15 UNDERTAKING: In accordance with Art. 164 of the Crim. Proc. Code of the RSFSR I have been warned of crimin- al liability under Arts. 92 and 95 of the Crim. Code of the RSFSR for refusal to give testimony and for giving false testimony. Korets (signature of the witness)
Verso of p. 159: interrogation record of witness M. A. Korets, 27.06.56
In the present case I can testify as follows: From my youth the principal aim of my life was participation in the building of a communist society. But more the decisive factor of all my actions In 1937 mass arrests, the violation of socialist legality and other perversions aroused in me doubts as to the correctness of the actions of the leader Sta- lin and of the clique of Yezhov and Beria. In this year I became acquainted with a student of IFLI (institute of philosoph. literature [illegible]) Pavel Kogan, who turned out to be a planted provocateur. I showed toward him a certain [illegible] with my doubts, he asked me to give [illegible] a factual basis for these doubts, whic h, supposedly, he was going to conduct against perversions in the work of building socialism. As a result of this provo- cation a document was written, in which [illegible] socialism of which I was accused. The remaining charges are an invention of the investigators, appl- ied to me beating and oth. unlawful methods of pressure. Never did I intend [illegible] to act against the party, Soviet power and the wor- king class. What had been done by me i s an error, [illegible] a delusion, but does not contain the elements of a crime. Especially Do not read what is crossed out Korets Korets [illegible]
p. 160
[in the margin] 160 [illegible], after the XX Congress of the Party, I want [illegible] with it, to give all my strength to the cause of communism. Therefore I write to the judicial authorities a request for the setting aside of the sentence and the discontinuance [illegible]. Since 1952, after my release, conscientiously I work where this proved necessary. Of this there bear witness the [illegible] refer- ence submitted by me and extracts from the employment record book. Opinions about me before the arrest can be given by the physicists Academician L.D. Landau and Corr. Member of the Academy of Sciences [illegible] Tamm [illegible]. The physicists figuring in my testimony Landau, Tamm, [illegible], Shubnikov, [illegible] and others never engaged in any anti-Soviet conversations with me and their testimony on this matter was comp osed by the investigator and signed by me under compulsion. At the present time almost all the persons listed are prom- inent figures of Soviet science, academicians, corr. members of the Academy, professors etc. Landau had no relation to the drawing up by me of the document and knew nothing about this. In the record of the court ses- sion this is recorded incorrectly. The testimony was written by me in my own hand Korets Do not read what is crossed out Korets [illegible] /Korkin/

P.161 Reference for the senior engineer of the Intaugol power grid

p.161 Reference for the senior engineer of the Intaugol power grid
[in the margin] 161 REFERENCE FOR THE SENIOR ENGINEER OF THE POWER GRID OF THE COMBINE "INTAUGOL" MUP KORETS Moisey Abramovich, 1908 year of birth, by origin from the townspeople, by personal status - an employee, education - higher. Comr. Korets [illegible] of the combine "Intaugol" of the month of April 1956. During the time of his work he showed himself an enterprising, conscientious and disciplined worker. System- atically he works at raising his technical knowledge. For good and honest work in production he was noted by an order for the combine with a commendation entered in his personal file. He takes an active part in the social-polit- ical life of the power-grid collective. The reference is given for presentation to the organs of Justice. [illegible] /VERSHADSKY/ [seal] [illegible] OF THE POWER GRID OF THE COMBINE "INTAUGOL" [illegible] /GRECHIN/ "13" June 1956

P. 162 Extract from the employment record book

p. 162 Extract from the employment record book
[in the margin] 161 REFERENCE FOR THE SENIOR ENGINEER OF THE POWER GRID OF THE COMBINE "INTAUGOL" MUP KORETS Moisey Abramovich, 1908 year of birth, by origin from the townspeople, by personal status - an employee, education - higher. Comr. Korets [illegible] of the combine "Intaugol" of the month of April 1956. During the time of his work he showed himself an enterprising, conscientious and disciplined worker. System- atically he works at raising his technical knowledge. For good and honest work in production he was noted by an order for the combine with a commendation entered in his personal file. He takes an active part in the social-polit- ical life of the power-grid collective. The reference is given for presentation to the organs of Justice. [illegible] /VERSHADSKY/ [seal] [illegible] OF THE POWER GRID OF THE COMBINE "INTAUGOL" [illegible] /GRECHIN/ "13" June 1956

Landau’s letter to the Central Military Prosecutor’s Office

Landau’s letter to the Central Military Prosecutor’s Office

A reading of the photograph, uncertain in places. Check it against the photograph.

[in the margin] [illegible] [in the margin] 54.48 [in the margin] [illegible] [seal] [illegible] [in the margin] K TO THE CHIEF MILITARY PROSECUTOR'S OFFICE I was closely acquainted with Moisey Abramovich KORETS during the course of 1934-38. In 1935-36 he worked at the Ukr. Physico-Technical Institute directly under my direction. The brevity [illegible] did not allow him to finish the work he had begun, but he managed to show himself as a capable young physicist-theore- tician. From the social-political side M.A. Korets was known to me at that time as a man fervently devoted to the cause [illegible] to further the cause of the development of science in the USSR he considered one of the principal tasks of his life. L. Landau Academician L.D. Landau 21 May 1956 [in the margin] [illegible] [in the margin] Korets [in the margin] [illegible]

P. 165 Survey report on the charge against Landau p. 166

p. 165 Survey report on the charge against Landau
Survey report [in the margin] 165 on archival-investigation case No. 621325 on the charge against Lev Davidovich Landau, born in 1908, a native of the city of Baku, before arrest - sen. scientific worker of the Inst. of Physical Problems of the AS USSR. L.D. Landau was arrested on 28 April 1938 with the sanction of Frinovsky on the char- ge of participation in an a/s wrecking organization and participation in the making of a c.r. leaflet (ld. 7) In the case there is one interrogation record of Landau, dated 3/VIII 1938, from which it is evident that Landau confessed himself gui- lty, named as his accomplices Shubnikov, Rozenkevich, Korets, Rumer and others, and testified that on 23 April he together with Korets in the apartment at his, Landau’s, drew up the text of a c.r. leaflet (ld. 34).
p. 166
- 2 - [in the margin] 166 Appended to the case are copies of the testimony of L.V. Rozenkevich of 12-13/VII 1937, of Korets M.A. of 25/V 38, of Yu.B. Rumer of [illegible] 38. Also appended to the case is a copy of the leaflet written by Korets (ld. 53). From the copy of the note of Dep. People's [illegible] of the NKVD of the USSR Kobulov it is evident that Landau on 8 April 1939 withdrew all his former testimony, as from forced ones (ld. 61) On 28 April 1939 in the case of Landau the NKVD of the USSR issued the following order: "In April 1938 there came into the NKVD of the USSR information to the effect that L.D. Landau together with [illegible] [illegible] of physics of the Moscow Pedagogical Inst. M.A. Korets drew up a counterrevolutionary leaflet in which they called the population of the USSR to an active strug- gle against Soviet power. A check of these data [illegible]

P. 167 p.169

p. 167
- 3 - [in the margin] 167 it was established that L.D. Landau and M.A. Korets are trying to make copies of this leaflet and to distribute it on 1 May 1938 during the demonstration. On the basis of these data, on 28 April 1938 L.D. Landau was arres- ted. At the investigation Landau confessed that he had joined in 1932 an anti-Soviet group that exis- ted at the Kharkov Physico-Technic- al Inst. Landau also admitted that together with other participants of the anti-Soviet group, for wrecking purposes, he disrupted the most important scientific work of the institute intended for the needs of the defense of the country. Having moved in 1936 from Khar- kov to Moscow, Landau did not cease his hostile activity against Soviet power. In Moscow Landau L.D., as he testified, drew into anti-Soviet work a progressiv-
p.169
- 5 - [in the margin] 169 3) Guided by the order of the People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSR to release Landau on the surety of Academician Kapitsa resolved: The arrested L.D. Landau from under custody to release, handing him over on the surety [illegible] to Academician Kapitsa "so that in the furth." (ld. 71-73) Military prosecutor of the GVP department Major [illegible] /Korkin/ 3/X 1958

P. 171 Note

p. 171 Note
- 2 - [in the margin] 171 L.D. Landau has been released from under custody. Military prosecutor of the GVP department Major [illegible] /Korkin/. Note. The present survey report [illegible] was drawn up on the basis of the note present in the materials of the check on arch.-inv. case No. 766025 on the charge against Shubni- kov L.V., Rozenkevich L.V., Gorsky V.S. (NT No. [illegible] 37). [illegible] 3/X 56

P. 172 Note on the review of the charge against Shubnikov and others. Landau’s letter p. 173 p. 174

p. 172 Note on the review of the charge against Shubnikov and others. Landau’s letter
Note [in the margin] 172 In the materials of the check on arch.-inv. case No. 766025 on the charge against L.V. Shubnikov and others there is an opinion of Academician, Hero of Socialis- t Labor L.D. Landau, of the following content: "I knew well L.V. Shubnikov, V.S. Gorsky and L.V. Rozenkevich, having wor- ked with them 3 years at the Ukrainian Physico-Technical Institute in Khar- kov. All of them are known to me as talen- ted scientists and as people fervently devoted to the cause of socialism. Of each of them separately I can say the following Lev Vasilyevich Shubnikov, undoubtedly, was one of the greatest physicists wor- king in the field of low temperatures not only here in the Union, but also on a wor- ld scale. Many of his works up to the present time are class- ical. To speak of his wrecking activity in the field of the physics of low temperatures is entirely absur-
p. 173
- 2 - [in the margin] 173 d, considering that he precisely was one of the creators of this field with us. His level of strain scien- kivalsya in that he conceived his work in Holland for work in the Motherland. The death inflicted on Soviet physics by the untimely perishing of L.V. Shubnikov is hard to overestimate. Vadim Sergeevich Gorsky was the grea- test specialist we had in X-ray structural analysis. It is pos- sible to say that up to the present time, despite the twenty years that have passed, we do not have in this field of physics a force equal to his. Lev Viktorovich Rozenkevich still had not managed to do much in science, because he changed his scientific specialty - he took up nuclear physics - only a few years before his arrest. However, already in this short time he came forward as a very talented worker and, undoubtedly, had in
p. 174
- 3 - [in the margin] 174 [illegible] there existed a role in the development with us of this important field of physics. (arch. inv. case No. 766025, ld. 230- 231, NT No. [illegible]-37) Military prosecutor of the GVP department Major [illegible] /Korkin/ 3/X 56

P. 175 Survey report on the charge against Shubnikov, Rozenkevich, Gorsky

p. 175 Survey report on the charge against Shubnikov, Rozenkevich, Gorsky
Survey report [in the margin] 175 on arch.-investig. case No. 766025 on the charge against Lev Vasilyevich Shubnikov, Lev Viktorovich Rozenkevich, Gorsky Vadim Sergeevich, former scientific workers of the Ukrainian Physico-Technic- al Institute in Kharkov. Shubnikov at first categorically denied his guilt (ld. 23), however then he specified his testimony and stated that at UFTI there existed a c.-r. Trotskyist organization consisting of Shubnikov, Leipunsky, [illegible], Korets, Landau, Rozenkevich, Gorsky, Brilliantov, [illegible] (ld. 25) Rozenkevich also confessed himself guil- ty (ld. 109) Gorsky did not confess himself guilty and did not confirm the testimony of Shubnikov and Rozenkevich (ld. 111, 114, 116). Shubnikov, Rozenkevich and Gorsky by a deci- sion of the NKVD of the USSR and the Prosecutor of the USSR of 28 October 1937 were shot on 8-10 November 1937 as participants in a c.r. Trotskyist- wrecking organization (ld. 168-180)

P. 184 Interrogation p.185 verso p.186 verso p. 187 verso

p. 184 Interrogation
In the present case I can testify as follows: The mass repressions of Soviet people which were carried out in our country in 1937 and which I considered unlawful, not corresponding to the cause of the cause of socialism, aroused in me a feeling of pain for the fate of the revolution in our country, a feeling of outra- ge at these repressions. I believed in our years was devoted to the cause of socialism and to the measure of my strength and possibilities fought for socialism. And when I saw that they arrest among many Soviet people, and not only people standing in high posts, but also simple people, I came to the conclusion that by such a path harm is done to the revolution, to the cause of socialism in our country, acting over lawless- nesses. Of concrete facts of these mass repressions at that time in Inte I knew very many, from these after all they also talked a lot, and I myself saw it, although no one of my relatives or close ones was arrested then. At the same time I want to emphasize that I did not believe in the rightness, in the justification of these repressions, since I could not know for sure, whet- her really, whether really they arrest this or that person, but I considered that such mass repressions are justified by nothing, they will not be so, moreover as I considered, they only harm the cause of our country. And so as a result of my feelings, as a result of this [illegible] and of talks [illegible] of mass repressions I wrote in 1937 that ill-fated leaflet for which I was tried in 1939. The writing of this leaflet is connected with a certain Kogan Korets
p.185
- 2 - [in the margin] 185 Pavel Davydovich, 1918-1942 (killed in the war). For the first time I met this Kogan back in 1935, when he was about 17, and I - 27 years. I simply saw him at an acquaintance of mine - Margalita Lvovna Saminskaya. At that time I was somewhat engaged in literary activity, Kogan, being still a boy, a novice, was trying in some way toward literature, therefore we with him at Margalita's, who liked to gather people and somehow to introduce them. Of course at that time I had no relations with Kogan, since he was still a boy. A second time I met him already in 1936, when he was a student of the Literary Institute - [illegible] institute, was in his 1st year and already himself was beginning to write some thing. We met again at Margalita's, who lived on 3rd [illegible] [illegible] (house No. I do not remember). Kogan then studied at our apartment some 2-3 times. He himself also with [illegible], but where - I do not know, and at his place we also did not go. Meeting with Kogan, we talked with him on literary subjects, about various current events in the country and in particular about the mass repressions being carried out. Concerning these repressions I expressed to Kogan my thoughts, about which I testified above. He agreed with me. And once in a conversation with Kogan which took place in March-April 1937 at my apartment, he told me that at their institute there is a group of students which is also outraged by these mass repressions, [illegible] of this terror or something of that sort - exactly now I do not remember. To this I said to Kogan that [illegible] Korets
Verso of p. 185: interrogation of M. A. Korets
[illegible] certainly, that this [illegible] is wrong. I told Kogan that one must turn with a protest to the masses, to the working people of our country, so that they would outrage the ruling [illegible] of the mass repressions. Kogan agreed with me, but said that they, the students, would not be able to do this by reason of their small experience, and asked me to write a leaflet. I agreed to do this. At the same time Kogan told me that the leaflet must be written in the name of an abstract worker of the party and that they have a resolution and they will make copies of this leaflet and distribute it among the population of Moscow in underground print shops. Some 2 days after this conversation I wrote the leaflet and handed it to Kogan. I wrote the leaflet alone, consulted no one and no one helped me. It seems the next day after this Kogan once more came to me and asked for the text [illegible] for the printing of the leaflet, I gave it to him, and then already on it, that same day I was arrested. Besides the leaflet, they brought a charge against me of wrecking, a fabricated one and also of the fact that. The investigation was conducted with the aim of violating socialist legality. I sat in Lefortovo prison, was subjected to bea tings, because they showed me at the investigation, including also the investigator [illegible], not testifying [illegible], except testimony that I wrote the leaflet. My testimony in court also does not fully corres- pond to reality. I knew that if I in court fully renounce my testimony given at the investigation, then this will be to my benefit, but this Korets
p.186
- 3 - [in the margin] 186 I did not want to, because I somehow hoped in court that it does not correspond to reality, but this [illegible] I do not remember. It must be said that already in court I admitted that Kogan was a provocateur. Already at the investigation I gave testimony against Kogan, but the investigator this [illegible] for some reason did not enter in the interrogation record. The question of summoning Kogan to court as a witness, to me in that the matter was refused. After this trial I did not see Kogan and do not know where he is and what is with him. There passed years about 15 after my arrest, when already I was living [illegible] with my wife, who told me that she had seen Kogan on a street in Moscow. Where Kogan is now, I do not know. Here is my [illegible]. From the accounts of Margalita - I also do not know, who with [illegible]. Further on the basis of these talks about Kogan, who [illegible] at the investigation and I came to the conclusion that he is a provocateur. Besides, at that time, when we ourselves were outraged by this did not think, besides Kogan, that his [illegible] [illegible], who although to fight against the mass [illegible] repressions, and I came self and this [illegible], through [illegible] he knew only Kogan. The aim of writing the leaflet and of distributing it - is to turn to the masses with a call of protest concerning the terror of those who fought in the country of mass repressions, in the first place, against Stalin, whom I considered the one to blame for the mass repressions, and against those who carried out these repressions, i.e. against the NKVD, its leaders. It is precisely in this sense that I repeat myself in the leaflet about the "Stalin clique". I never thought that the policy of mass repressions - Korets
Verso of p. 186: interrogation of M. A. Korets
This violates our whole people, our whole government, therefore will not give, [illegible] the people [illegible] against the party and the government in general. At the present time, in the light of the decisions of the XX Congress of the CPSU I can say with a clear conscience that, having written this leaflet, I committed no crime. My error consists in that then in 1937 I did not foresee that the people together with the party would sweep away in the end the temporarily temporary [illegible] I thought then that this was not yet, as in an organization, and wrote the leaflet, although I realize now that then to write it was. But even having written it I did not commit a crime, since according to the Constitution of the USSR I had the right to freedom of speech, which consists in: In in defense of the cause of socialism. In my leaflet, in what [illegible], I wanted only to help this cause, and did not think, but was inflicting anything against Soviet power, against [illegible] the party. Question: How do you understand the words in the leaflet: "The economy of the country is falling apart. Famine is approaching"? Answer: These words must be understood in the sense that mass repressions can bring the country to the point that that the economy will fall apart and famine will come, since [illegible] [illegible] the people. Question: How do you understand the words "The Stalin [illegible] of Kogan [illegible] on the principles of economic [illegible] [illegible]"? Answer: This, of course, [illegible] [illegible] and [illegible] [illegible]. I had in mind that in those years [illegible] and enemies of the people, whom we ourselves [illegible] 1930, that mass repressions [illegible] [illegible] the people Korets
p. 187
- 4 - [in the margin] 187 and of socialism. Question: What caused the writing of the leaflet: the facts of the mass repressions or something else besides? Answer: The writing of the leaflet was caused only by this, so as to outrage the ruling [illegible] of the mass repressions. Besides, then I in [illegible], i.e. in 1937 I condemned, carried out at that time [illegible] [illegible] and also measures of the party and the government, such as the permitting of abortions, [illegible] of criminal liability for [illegible] of 12-14 years, the introduction in the country of the passport system, but this was not the main opinion but [illegible] a question. On the writing of the leaflet this had no significance. Question: At the beginning of the judicial investigation you stated that you in any counterrevolutionary organization did not belong, and then testified that you were a participant [illegible] together with Kogan. How is this contradiction to be explained? Answer: At the investigation I was told to the effect that supposedly I am a participant in a c.-r. organization consisting of: Landau and others. Nothing of the sort existed, therefore I renounced this at the trial. But when they announced to me [illegible], that I had belonged to a counterrevolutionary organization together with Kogan, then on this question I testified that [illegible] acknowledged myself in [illegible] together with Kogan, and in this sense said at the trial, in this [illegible], but did not consider it counterrevolutionary. In addition besides Kogan, no one knew, and no [illegible] measures did I carry out. Question: From the record of the judicial investigation it is evident that your leaflet was [illegible] against [illegible] the party and the government, against "the clique of [illegible] Bukharin" Korets
Verso of p. 187: interrogation of M. A. Korets
How is this to be understood? Answer: I did not appeal neither at the trial, but in [illegible] this [illegible] [illegible]. I shall repeat [illegible] against [illegible] mass repressions and against those who carried them out, as I testified above. Question: In court you testified that concerning the leaflet you consulted with Landau. [illegible] this? Answer: In court I did not say this, with Landau concerning the leaflet I never spoke. In [illegible] to me [illegible] Answer: [illegible] Question: In court you, being [illegible], testified: Landau on ld. 24-25 concerning the leaflet. [illegible] this? Answer: I knew of no testimony of Landau, at the investigation did not interrogate. Question: In court in one case you stated that you wrote the leaflet on your own initiative, and in another testified that this [illegible] organization with [illegible] of Kogan. How is this to be understood? Answer: When I spoke of my initiative, I had in mind the content and the text, but the occasion of the mass repressions, while the immediate [illegible] of the leaflet was proposed to me by Kogan, whom I considered a provocateur. Question: For what were you arrested in 1935? Answer: In 1935 I was arrested and there was brought a charge under Art. 58-10 [illegible] in that in [illegible] I [illegible] [illegible] [illegible] [illegible] of the institute where I then worked. [illegible] [illegible] in the city of [illegible] on [illegible] [illegible], and was released, since I cases not [illegible]. Korets

The text is taken from photographs of the case file. Words that could not be made out are marked [illegible]. Where a page is too faint, only the photograph has been left.

To the top